The full rankingFantasy and Pick'em
Scores are out of 10 and come from funded accounts: odds and fees, payout speed, markets, the app and support.
6 reviews, average score 6.3
Top 6 at a glance
Darker bars sit below the average for this list.
Ranked by score
| # | Review | Category | Price | Score | Open |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  UnderdogBest for: Best ball and draft players who want one polished appA polished drafts and pick'em app with strong best ball and a 4.8 App Store rating. The sportsbook was limited to one state and is closing, pick'em access varies by state, withdrawals wait on manual review, and winners report account restrictions. | Fantasy and Pick'em | Free to join | ||
| 2 |  ParlayPlayBest for: Pick'em players who compare prices pick by pickParlayPlay's per-pick multipliers can beat a fixed table on the same slip: a reported 35x on six picks against 25x at PrizePicks, which lowers the break-even hit rate from about 58.5% to 55.3% per pick. Higher ceilings come with a $30 reported withdrawal minimum, slower payouts and about 27 states. | Fantasy and Pick'em | Free to join | ||
| 3 |  SleeperBest for: Fantasy football players who want occasional Picks entriesSleeper is the best-liked fantasy league app of its kind, and the Picks product is a decent add-on rather than a leader. Reviewers report a narrower menu and a larger house edge than PrizePicks or Underdog, so the app suits fantasy fans more than dedicated pick'em players. | Fantasy and Pick'em | Free to join | ||
| 4 |  ChalkboardBest for: Pick'em players curious about peer-to-peer contestsChalkboard has an interesting idea: players compete against each other instead of a house, with Cash Out and pick insurance on top. But the public pages never state the rake, the offer wording contradicts itself and it mixes real-money play with a sweepstakes mode and card packs. Interesting, not yet proven better value. | Fantasy and Pick'em | Free to join | ||
| 5 |  Betr PicksBest for: Existing pick'em players chasing sign-up and deposit bonusesA pick'em app for players who want promotions first. Betr does not publish a clear multiplier table in its terms, entry limits sit in separate House Rules, and the best deposit matches are invite-only. PrizePicks and Underdog are easier to price. Use Betr as a side account for its bonuses. | Fantasy and Pick'em | Free to join | ||
| 6 |  PrizePicksBest for: Casual players staking small amounts for funFast and simple, but the payout table builds in a margin of 25% at best and over 40% at worst on fair 50/50 picks, far above a -110 sportsbook line. A casual game at small stakes; a poor tool for anyone chasing profit. | Fantasy and Pick'em | Free to join |