How we test crypto exchanges
A score on Fillwright comes from an account we opened, money we moved and a checklist we run the same way on every exchange.
Opening the account
We sign up as a new customer, note which documents the exchange asks for at each verification tier, how long approval took and which limits each tier unlocks. If an exchange will not serve a country, we say which one and how we found out.
Deposits, trades and withdrawals
We fund the account through at least one bank or card rail and one crypto deposit, buy and sell on the spot market with both market and limit orders, and test futures or other products where the exchange is built around them.
Then we withdraw, both crypto to our own wallet and fiat to a bank account where the exchange supports it, and time each withdrawal from request to arrival.
The checklist
- Deposit rails: which ones cleared, and what each one cost.
- Withdrawal time: minutes from request to funds in our wallet or bank.
- Fee schedule: maker, taker, spread and network fees we actually paid, against the published page.
- Licence: the regulator, the register entry and the entity that holds our account.
- Proof of reserves: published, audited by a named firm, or absent.
- Verification: documents asked for and limits unlocked at each tier.
- Support: how a ticket was answered and how long it took.
How the score works
Scores run from 0 to 10 with one decimal. Costs, withdrawal reliability and regulatory standing carry the most weight; the trading interface, product range and support follow. An exchange that held a withdrawal without explanation, or that serves readers where it holds no licence, cannot score well however low its fees are.
The rankings sort every published review by that score. Exchanges in different categories are scored on the same scale, so a decentralized exchange and a regulated broker can sit side by side.
Updates and corrections
Fees and licences change. When we find a change, or a reader reports one, we check it, update the review and add a correction note at the end of the article saying what changed. Write to us from the contact page.