The routine
- Open an account the normal way. We go through sign-up and identity checks as a customer would and note how long verification takes and what it asks for.
- Fund it. We deposit with the payment methods most readers use and record every fee and delay between our bank and a usable balance.
- Use it. On exchanges we place market and limit orders and compare the fee we paid with the published schedule. On wallets we set up the device or app, back it up, restore it and sign transactions.
- Get the money out. We withdraw to a bank and to a self-custody wallet and time both. A platform that is easy to fund and slow to leave is scored on the second part.
- Check the paperwork. Licences, proof-of-reserves reports, security incidents and the terms that decide what happens to your funds in a dispute.
What the score means
The score is out of 10 and uses one decimal. It weighs fees, safety and custody, the deposit and withdrawal experience, product range, and support. A score compares a product with the others in its own category: a hardware wallet is not marked down for lacking futures.
- 9.0 and above: we would use it ourselves without reservations.
- 8.0 to 8.9: a strong choice with a weakness worth knowing about.
- 6.0 to 7.9: fine for some people; read who it suits before you sign up.
- 5.0 to 5.9: works, but a better option exists for most readers.
- Below 5.0: we would not deposit. The score bar turns red.
Keeping it current
We revisit a review when fees, licences or custody arrangements change, and when readers report a problem we can reproduce. If the score moves, the review says so.
What a review cannot tell you
We test with modest amounts in a handful of countries. Your fees, limits and available products depend on where you live and how much you trade. A review is a record of what happened to us, not a promise of what will happen to you, and it is not financial advice.