How we review
; method, scoring and updates
Weeks, not an afternoon
A product joins a real routine before we write a word: headphones go on the commute and into calls, an espresso machine makes the morning coffee, a robot vacuum runs on the floors it was bought for, a backpack goes on an actual trip. Most problems that matter show up in the second or third week, so that is when the notes start to count.
The steps
- Read the maker's claimsSpecifications, price and warranty are taken from the maker's own page and listed on the review as the maker states them.
- Use it the way you wouldDaily use in a home, an office or outdoors, in the conditions the product is sold for, with the settings most owners will use.
- Measure what changes the decisionBattery life, noise, time to brew, run time on a charge: we measure where a number would change who should buy it, and say how.
- Compare with the alternativesEvery verdict names who should skip the product and what to consider instead, including cheaper options when they are good enough.
What the score means
Scores run from 0 to 10 with one decimal. They weigh how well the product does its main job, how it holds up over the test, how pleasant it is to live with, and whether the price is fair for what you get. A 9 is rare and means we would buy it again ourselves. A 7 is a good product with a clear catch. Below 6, most people should look elsewhere.
Scores compare products within a category best, but the rankings put every review in one list for a quick overview.
Pictures
Pictures are captures of the maker's own pages and photos of the product, shown as they are: never recoloured or cropped to hide a detail. Captions say what each picture shows.
Updates and corrections
Prices change, firmware updates fix or break things, and new models replace old ones. When something changes the verdict, we update the review and note it on the page. Corrections are marked as corrections.